Gracey’s Pizza Review: New Haven Perfection Finds a Permanent Home in Central London

Gracey’s Pizza at Arcade Food Hall (Tottenham Court Road) is the long-awaited permanent London home for what many consider one of the best pizzerias in the UK. Originally a "word-of-mouth" cult favorite from St Albans, owners Grace and James Newman have brought their distinct New Haven-inspired style to the heart of the West End.

Gracey’s isn't your standard Neapolitan or New York slice. It draws heavily from New Haven (Connecticut) style, or "apizza."

• The Crust: Expect a "low and slow" bake that results in a light, thin, and notably charred base. It has a distinctive chew and a "leopard-spotted" crust that holds up under heavy toppings without going floppy.

• The Vibe: Tucked into the back of the vibrant Arcade Food Hall, the space feels like a hybrid of a cozy neighborhood joint and a high-energy urban food market. It’s perfect for a quick lunch or a casual group dinner with cocktails.

  
  

  

The Verdict

Pros:

• Unrivaled Crust: One of the most technically impressive pizza bases in London right now.

• Consistency: Despite moving from a tiny St Albans shop to a busy food hall, the quality hasn't dipped.

• Variety: The addition of the Grandma Square and unique toppings makes it stand out in a crowded London pizza scene.

  
  

Cons:

• The Buzz: Because it’s located in Arcade, it can get loud and hectic during peak hours. If you want a quiet, intimate date night, this might be too high-energy.

• Char: If you don't like "leopard spotting" or a bit of black on your crust, the New Haven style might taste "burnt" to you (though to purists, that’s where the flavor is).

  
  

Gracey’s is a mandatory stop for any pizza enthusiast. It brings a unique American regional style to London with zero pretension and maximum flavor.